Students at the University of New Mexico rejected BS at a 14 to 4 vote. Naturally, pro-Israel students decried the proposed resolution for its bias. But even neutral observers criticized the resolution for its negative effects on campus climate. The
student newspaper reports:
Sen.
Tori Pryor said it was a problem that the resolution didn’t focus on
the climate at UNM and the potential impact the resolution would have
domestically. She
cited previous resolutions, such as legislation condemning Islamophobia
and supporting undocumented students, as ones that were successful
because they did not “shift the climate of fear” from one group to
another, as she and many senators believed Resolution 12S would if
passed. “You
have to value perception more than, if not just as much as, you value
intention,” she said. “We want safety for everyone. We listen to our
Palestinian students; should we not listen to our Israeli students?”
As at prior votes, anti-Israel students made a desperate effort to pass the resolution by removing any and all references to the BS movement itself but, as before, this ploy failed to sway those in the room who saw a transparent link between the bigotry of the resolution and the bigotry of the movement:
Calzadillas
Chavez, one of three senators who sponsored the resolution, proposed an
amendment removing two clauses referring to the Boycott, Divestment and
Sanctions movement that UNM must take part in, citing that as the main
source of contention. It passed, but Balis and Lobos for Israel were not swayed. “No
matter what you strike, the thing is the same,” Balis said. “It’s still
calling for BDS even if you don’t talk about it. For that reason we
still can’t accept this.”